Roofing metal vs shingles: 7 Powerful Reasons to Choose Wisely

Making the Big Roofing Decision: Metal or Shingles?

Roofing metal vs shingles is one of the most important decisions homeowners face when it’s time for a roof replacement. Here’s a quick comparison to help you understand the key differences:

When it comes to protecting your home, few decisions have as much long-term impact as your choice of roofing material. The debate between metal roofing and asphalt shingles isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s about durability, value, and peace of mind over decades.

While asphalt shingles currently cover about 80% of American homes, metal roofing has doubled its market share since 2015, now claiming 12% of the remodeling market. This shift isn’t happening by accident. Homeowners are increasingly looking beyond the initial price tag to consider the full lifetime value of their roofing investment.

I’m Adam Kadziola from DML USA Metal Roofing, a leading Illinois manufacturer of metal roofing products since 2007, and I’ve helped countless homeowners steer the roofing metal vs shingles decision with honest, data-driven guidance. My years in manufacturing and home renovation have given me unique insights into what makes a roof truly valuable over its entire lifespan.

Basic Roofing metal vs shingles glossary:
– Roofing material cost comparison

Roofing Metal vs Shingles: Quick-Glance Showdown

When it’s time for a new roof, Illinois homeowners often find themselves at a crossroads: stick with familiar asphalt shingles or make the leap to metal roofing? Let’s break down what really matters in this important decision:

I remember talking with Mike from Naperville last summer after his metal roof installation. He told me with a laugh, “I was sweating bullets over the price tag, but now I watch my neighbors replacing their shingle roofs for the second time since I moved in. Turns out I’m not so bad with money after all!”

More info about DML resources

Why the “Roofing metal vs shingles” debate matters

The roofing metal vs shingles conversation isn’t just industry chatter—it directly impacts your home’s protection, your wallet, and even your local environment.

Think about it: with about 5 million roof replacements happening yearly across America, we’re talking about billions in spending decisions. Homes with quality metal roofing typically recover between 85% and 95% of installation costs when sold. Meanwhile, if you own your home long-term, you’ll likely replace an asphalt roof 2-3 times during the lifespan of just one metal roof.

As Sarah from Springfield told me recently, “I was signing papers for my third asphalt roof in four decades when my contractor gently asked if I was tired of repeating the same expensive cycle. That honest question changed my perspective completely—metal made so much more sense for the long run.”

Roofing metal vs shingles: myth-busting facts

Let’s clear up some stubborn misconceptions in the roofing metal vs shingles debate:

That noisy rain sound? Modern metal roofs installed over proper decking and insulation are only about 8 decibels louder than asphalt—a difference most people barely notice. Today’s installations include sound-dampening underlayment that effectively eliminates the old-fashioned “tin roof” effect many people worry about.

Worried about lightning? Metal roofing doesn’t attract lightning at all. Lightning strikes the highest point in an area regardless of what it’s made of. In fact, metal’s non-combustible nature actually makes your home safer if lightning does strike.

HOA concerns? While some associations have restrictions, many have updated their guidelines as metal roofing has evolved to include beautiful styles that convincingly mimic traditional materials. Today’s metal roofing comes in a variety of textures and over 100 colors that can satisfy even strict neighborhood requirements.

Can you walk on a metal roof? Absolutely. Properly installed metal roofs can handle careful foot traffic without damage. Like any roofing material, you’ll want to use proper techniques, but the old “too fragile to walk on” myth simply isn’t true.

As Tom, a roofing contractor with 30 years of experience, told me at a recent home show, “Most objections I hear about metal roofing are based on information that was outdated when I started my career. Today’s systems have engineered solutions for virtually all those old concerns.”

Counting the Dollars: Cost & Lifetime Value

When comparing roofing metal vs shingles, many homeowners get a bit of sticker shock looking at those initial price tags. But here’s the thing – focusing only on upfront costs misses the bigger financial picture that unfolds over decades of homeownership.

Upfront sticker shock vs 50-year math

Yes, metal roofing requires a bigger initial investment – there’s no way around that truth. A quality standing seam metal roof might run you between $10-$16 per square foot installed, while corrugated metal panels come in more affordably at $4-$7 per square foot. Metal shingles typically land somewhere in between at $8-$14 per square foot.

Compare this to the familiar asphalt options: basic 3-tab shingles at $3-$5 per square foot installed, or architectural shingles at $4.50-$7 per square foot, and it’s easy to see why so many homeowners default to asphalt.

But here’s where the math gets interesting. Let’s look at a typical 2,000 square foot home over a 50-year period:

With asphalt shingles, you’re looking at about $8,000 for that initial installation. But then around year 20, you’ll need replacement #1 at roughly $12,800 (factoring in that pesky 2.5% annual inflation). By year 40, you’re facing replacement #2 at approximately $20,480. Add it all up, and your 50-year investment totals a whopping $41,280.

Now for the metal roof scenario: Your initial installation might be $16,000, and you might need a repainting around year 40 for about $5,000. Total 50-year cost? Just $21,000.

That’s a lifetime savings of over $20,000 with metal roofing – and we haven’t even talked about energy savings, potential insurance discounts, or increased home value yet!

As Mike from Springfield told us after installing his metal roof last year: “I almost choked when I saw the initial quote, but then my contractor showed me what I’d spend over the next 40 years with asphalt. Suddenly, metal seemed like the bargain of the century!”

Why Choose Metal Roofing

Insurance and tax credits—money you keep

The financial benefits of choosing metal don’t stop at avoiding replacement costs – there’s actual money coming back to your pocket too.

Insurance Premium Discounts can be substantial. Many insurance companies recognize the superior protection metal roofs provide against fire, wind, and impact damage, offering premium reductions between 10-35%. For many homeowners, this translates to hundreds of dollars saved each year. Over decades, we’re talking thousands back in your pocket.

The Federal Tax Credits situation has gotten even better recently. Thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, homeowners can claim a 30% tax credit (up to $3,000) for qualifying metal roof installations on primary residences through 2032. That’s potentially thousands off your tax bill in the first year alone.

For our Illinois neighbors, there are additional Illinois-Specific Incentives worth exploring. Many state and local programs offer extra incentives for energy-efficient home improvements, including qualifying metal roofing installations.

One of our customers in Chicago shared: “Between my insurance discount and the energy tax credit, I recovered about 15% of my metal roof cost before the first year was even over. It’s like the roof started paying me back immediately!”

The numbers tell a clear story – while metal roofing costs more upfront, it starts working to save you money almost immediately, and those savings compound dramatically over time.

Progressive study on roof premiums

Muscle on the Rafters: Performance, Lifespan & Extreme Weather

When it comes to protecting your home from Mother Nature’s fury, the roofing metal vs shingles comparison reveals significant differences, especially here in Illinois where weather can swing from scorching summers to brutal winters virtually overnight.

How long will each roof really last?

Let’s talk longevity – because this is where the rubber really meets the road (or where the metal meets the rafters!).

Metal roofing systems are the marathon runners of the roofing world. Steel panels will faithfully protect your home for 40-70 years, while aluminum options push beyond the 50-year mark. If you’re feeling particularly fancy, copper and zinc roofing can last a century or more – possibly outliving the house itself! Manufacturers back this impressive durability with warranties typically spanning 30-50 years.

Asphalt shingles, by comparison, are more like middle-distance runners. 3-tab shingles typically last 15-20 years, while architectural shingles might stretch to 20-30 years. Even premium shingles top out around 25-35 years, with warranties generally covering 15-30 years.

But here’s what the brochures don’t always tell you: shingle warranties often switch to pro-rated coverage after the initial period, and some only cover materials, not the labor for replacement. As one of our roofing experts likes to say, “The functional life of asphalt shingles in the Midwest is typically around 17 years, while their aesthetic life—before they start looking worn and faded—can be as short as 5-7 years.”

Storm season scorecard

Living in Illinois means your roof faces a gauntlet of weather challenges – from summer tornadoes to winter blizzards and everything in between.

When it comes to wind resistance, metal roofing stands tall against gusts up to 140 mph – strong enough to withstand an F2 tornado. Traditional 3-tab asphalt shingles begin to fail at just 60-70 mph, while architectural shingles can resist winds up to 110-130 mph with proper installation.

Hail storms are where the difference becomes particularly striking. Metal roofing might pick up some cosmetic dents from severe hail but rarely fails functionally, earning a Class 4 impact rating (the highest available). Meanwhile, quarter-sized hail can significantly damage 3-tab shingles, and even architectural shingles often surrender to golf ball-sized hail.

For fire resistance, metal roofing earns a Class A rating (the highest possible) and is naturally non-combustible. Asphalt shingles can achieve Class A ratings with proper underlayment, but the material itself contains petroleum compounds that will burn when exposed to sufficient heat or embers.

Winter brings its own challenges, and metal’s snow and ice performance offers peace of mind. The smooth surface naturally sheds snow, and darker color options can help melt accumulation. Asphalt shingles, however, are more prone to developing ice dams and can suffer damage from repeated freeze-thaw cycles.

I was particularly struck by what a Lake County homeowner told me after last year’s severe hailstorm: “My neighbor’s asphalt roof was destroyed and required complete replacement. My metal roof had some cosmetic denting but remained 100% waterproof. The insurance adjuster was impressed—and so was I!”

When extreme weather hits, the roofing metal vs shingles debate often resolves itself through real-world performance. Your roof isn’t just about looks—it’s your home’s first line of defense against whatever Mother Nature throws your way.

Green & Cool: Efficiency, Environment & Incentives

The environmental impact of your roofing choice extends far beyond your property line. The roofing metal vs shingles comparison reveals significant differences in sustainability and energy efficiency.

Cutting utility bills the reflective way

Ever wondered why your air conditioner works overtime in summer? Your roof might be the culprit. Metal roofing acts like a shield against the sun’s heat, reflecting 70-80% of solar radiation instead of absorbing it like a sponge.

What does this mean for your wallet? Many homeowners see a 7-25% reduction in cooling costs after switching to metal. Think about those scorching Illinois August afternoons when your attic turns into a sauna. Metal roofing can reduce those temperatures by up to 30°F!

“I was skeptical about the energy claims,” admits Frank from Naperville, “until my first summer electric bill after installing my metal roof. The difference was so noticeable, I thought the utility company had made a mistake.”

Even if you prefer darker colors for your home’s aesthetic, don’t worry. Modern cool roof coatings use special pigments that improve reflectivity regardless of color. Meanwhile, even the best “cool” asphalt shingles typically only reflect 25-35% of solar radiation.

As our energy auditor friend puts it: “In Chicago’s hot summers, the difference between metal and asphalt can mean hundreds of dollars in cooling costs. I’ve measured attic temperatures 20-25 degrees cooler under metal roofs compared to similar homes with asphalt.”

Planet points & local perks

When we talk about sustainability, the numbers tell a compelling story. Most metal roofing contains 25-95% recycled content to begin with, and it’s 100% recyclable at the end of its life. Your grandchildren’s car might contain parts of your roof someday!

Contrast this with asphalt shingles, which contribute approximately 11 million tons to U.S. landfills annually. That’s roughly 3,000 Olympic-sized swimming pools of waste each year. Since asphalt is petroleum-based and rarely recycled in practice, its environmental footprint is substantial.

“I calculated that choosing metal meant I wouldn’t be sending 3-4 layers of asphalt shingles to the landfill over my home’s lifetime,” shared Emma from Oak Park. “That environmental impact was worth the extra upfront cost to me.”

For the eco-conscious Illinois homeowner, additional green incentives sweeten the deal:

Local utility rebates often reward energy-efficient roofing choices. Several Illinois power companies offer cash back for verified cool roof installations.

Property tax incentives in certain Illinois municipalities reward sustainable building practices, potentially saving you hundreds annually.

LEED credits become accessible if you’re pursuing green building certification.

Perhaps most exciting for forward-thinking homeowners is the seamless compatibility with solar panels. Metal roofing, especially standing seam varieties, allows for solar panel installation without a single roof penetration. The panels simply clamp onto the raised seams, preserving your roof’s integrity while generating clean energy.

Metal roofing even makes rainwater harvesting more practical, as it doesn’t leach harmful chemicals or granules into your collection system.

U.S. DOT data on shingle waste

Style, Installation & Maintenance: Your Practical Checklist + FAQs

Today’s metal roofing offers aesthetic versatility that surprises many homeowners. The roofing metal vs shingles decision no longer means sacrificing curb appeal for durability.

“Roofing metal vs shingles” look & noise FAQs

“Won’t my house look like an industrial building?” This is one of the first concerns I hear from homeowners considering metal roofing. The truth is, modern metal roofing has come a long way from the corrugated barn roofs of yesteryear.

Today’s options include sleek standing seam panels for contemporary homes, dimensional metal shingles that mimic traditional asphalt, authentic-looking metal shake that’s nearly indistinguishable from cedar, neat metal tile profiles, and even stone-coated options with rich, textured appearances. With over 100 color choices and multiple finishes, you can find metal roofing to complement any architectural style from Victorian to ultra-modern.

As for the rain noise question – I smile every time this comes up. When properly installed over solid decking with appropriate underlayment (which is standard practice for homes), a metal roof is just barely louder than asphalt during a downpour – about 6-8 decibels difference. Many of our customers report they were actually disappointed they couldn’t hear more rain sounds! As one homeowner told me, “I was hoping for that cozy rain sound, but I can barely tell the difference from my old shingle roof.”

Will your home stand out with a metal roof? Yes, but for all the right reasons. While metal roofing was once limited to agricultural and commercial buildings, it’s now mainstream across all housing styles. I’ve seen countless installations where neighbors had no idea a metal roof was installed because it blended so naturally with the neighborhood aesthetic.

Installation speed & skill FAQs

“How long will I have workers tramping around my house?” It’s a fair question. Installation timelines vary, but generally, asphalt shingles can be completed in 1-3 days for an average home, while metal roofing typically takes 3-7 days. The extra time reflects the precision required for proper metal roof installation – and believe me, that attention to detail directly impacts how your roof performs for decades to come.

One of metal’s hidden advantages is that in many cases, it can be installed right over one layer of existing asphalt shingles. This approach saves you money on tear-off and disposal fees, adds another insulation layer, reduces landfill waste, and shortens the installation timeline. Just remember that a professional assessment is necessary first to ensure your structure can handle the weight and that the existing roof deck is sound.

Weather concerns? Metal roofing can be installed year-round in most climates, including winter conditions that might delay shingle installation. Unlike asphalt shingles, which require warm temperatures to properly seal, metal panels aren’t temperature-sensitive during installation.

For solar enthusiasts, standing seam metal roofs offer a significant advantage – panels can be clamped directly to the seams without putting a single hole in your roof. This eliminates potential leak points and preserves your warranty. I’ve seen homeowners save thousands on solar installation with this method compared to mounting on asphalt shingles.

Care & upkeep FAQs

If you’re like most homeowners I talk to, you’re probably wondering about maintenance requirements. The good news: metal roofing is incredibly low-maintenance. An annual visual inspection, clearing debris from valleys and gutters, checking flashings, and occasionally washing off dirt or environmental residue is typically all that’s needed.

Contrast this with asphalt shingles, which often require regular checks for cracked, curled, or missing shingles, treatments for moss and algae growth, monitoring of granule loss, and increasingly frequent repairs as they age.

“Will I need to repaint my metal roof?” Not for a very long time. High-quality metal roofing with premium PVDF coatings (like Kynar 500®) maintains its appearance for decades. Most metal roofs won’t need repainting for 30-50 years. When repainting eventually becomes necessary, it costs significantly less than a full roof replacement.

Repairs are another area where metal shines. While they’re rarely needed, when damage does occur, individual panels can often be replaced without disturbing the entire roof, small punctures can be sealed with appropriate materials, and exposed fastener systems may need fastener replacement after a few decades of service.

As a roofing contractor with over 30 years of experience recently told me: “I’ve replaced hundreds of asphalt roofs due to failure, but I’ve rarely had to replace a properly installed metal roof. Most metal roof service calls are for minor issues that are quickly resolved – often in less time than it takes to diagnose problems with a failing asphalt roof.”

Products

Conclusion

The roofing metal vs shingles debate isn’t just an academic exercise—it’s a decision that will impact your home, your wallet, and your peace of mind for decades to come.

If you’re planning to move within the next 5-10 years and your primary concern is minimizing upfront expenses, asphalt shingles might make the most sense for your situation. There’s no shame in making a practical choice that aligns with your current circumstances and future plans.

But if you’re settling in for the long haul—or simply value lasting quality over temporary solutions—metal roofing presents a compelling case. The numbers don’t lie: despite the higher initial investment, metal roofing typically saves homeowners thousands over its lifetime through eliminated replacement cycles, reduced maintenance costs, energy efficiency, and potential insurance discounts.

For those of us living in Illinois, where weather can swing from sweltering summers to brutal winters (sometimes in the same week!), a roof’s performance matters tremendously. Whether you’re dealing with Chicago’s lake effect snow, Central Illinois’ tornado risks, or the Mississippi River region’s humidity, metal roofing stands as your home’s first line of defense against whatever Mother Nature throws your way.

At DML USA Metal Roofing, we’ve been crafting premium metal roofing systems right here in Illinois since 2007. We understand the unique challenges Midwestern homes face because we live with them too. Our products aren’t just manufactured—they’re engineered specifically for our region’s climate extremes, offering superior protection against fire, wind, and impact damage while qualifying for valuable energy tax credits.

As you weigh your options, we encourage you to think beyond today’s price tag. Consider how long you’ll be in your home, what weather challenges you regularly face, what aesthetic best complements your property, and how your roofing choice aligns with your values around sustainability and long-term value.

The roof above your head is more than just building material—it’s what protects everything and everyone you cherish inside your home. Whether you choose metal or asphalt, make your decision with both eyes open, considering both today’s budget realities and tomorrow’s long-term value.

We’re here to help whenever you’re ready to explore your options further.

More info about our metal roof options